cthulhushrugged. The film tells a story of Mulan (voiced by Ming-Na Wen), a girl who impersonates a man and joins the army in place of her This creates many historical inaccuracies which makes the Asian culture interchangeable "others". com/XiranJayZhao/status/1314 Aug 11, 2022 · The film "Mulan: Rise of a Warrior" embraces this darker vibe and explores her 12 years in the army as a time steeped in brutality. British mythology includes Queen Cordelia, for example, the daughter of King Leir, immortalized in Shakespeare’s play, King Lear. Does Mulan have historical accuracy? Scholars generally consider Mulan to be a fictional character. The legend says that she lived during the Northern Wei dynasty, whereas the movie is set during the Han dynasty. com/kingsandgenerals and use code kingsandgenerals to get 70% off a 3-year plan and an extra month for free. For starters, the ballad was set sometime in the fifth century. One of the biggest problems with looking for historical inaccuracies in Mulan is that the movie intentionally unmoors itself from time and place. • 5 yr. Although the whole film told a Chinese story, it actually still showed huge differences between the film and genuine Chinese ancient culture. Well, whether that's true or not comes down to what we consider "historical. Like most historical movie I've come to find that people don't always tell the whole truth of the stories they are putting on the big screen. Mulan is based on a legend that has been adapted over thousands of years. 15 Jun 2024. Originating as an ancient Chinese ballad during the late Northern Wei Dynasty, the tale likely draws inspiration from the Tuoba tribe's culture. X. In 1998, Disney released the animated film Mulan, which is inspired by a legend that probably originated from the Ballad of Mulan in the Northern Wei, a dynasty ruling northern China between the 4th and the 6th centuries CE. She has no knowledge of weapons or physical combat (Mulan). Gone are the Huns and its vicious leader Shan Yu. The Rise Of Rome: 1. She fights with the men ‚ and even after her identity is made true‚ she fights and defeats the Huns‚ and saves the Emperor‚ bringing great honor to her family (Mulan). Historical Accuracies of Mulan. I have to give EasyTech credit as the bonus campaign does say "legend" in it. She died shortly after at the age of Template:SimilarName Mulan is a 1998 American animated musical action comedy-drama film produced by Walt Disney Feature Animation for Walt Disney Pictures. Award. Larry Holzwarth - September 15, 2020. Genre: Action-Adventure, Animation, Family, Musical. Jul 11, 2019 · The internet in China has exploded with excitement over Disney’s viral new “Mulan” trailer, but some have bemoaned the glaring historical and geographical inaccuracies in the short clip Apr 21, 2024 · The story of Mulan first appeared in the “Ballad of Mulan,” a folk song from the Northern Wei Dynasty (386–534 AD). Jul 11, 2019 · The internet in China has exploded with excitement over Disney ’s viral new “ Mulan ” trailer, but some have bemoaned the glaring historical and geographical inaccuracies in the short clip Sep 14, 2020 · Chinese audiences mocked it for other reasons, including historical inaccuracies and stereotyping. The Hunchback Of Notre Dame. Rewrites, including the replacement of iconic characters such as Grandma Fa and Mushu with new, more The Real Legend of Hua Mulan. In the Disney movie, Mulan’s identity as a woman is discovered by accident after she was wounded. Nov 5, 2023 · After 10 years it's time to make our own original series follow us on X for more https://www. Mulan as depicted in the album Gathering Gems of Beauty ( 畫麗珠萃秀) ( Qing dynasty; ca 18th century). [1] The Jul 3, 2017 · 10 Films With Glaring Historical Inaccuracies. This unprecedented release only fed into further boycott, as the public accused Disney of being money hungry. ago. Featuring the voice talents of Ming-Na Wen and Eddie Murphy, this adventure takes the viewer on a wondrous journey through the culture and feelings of the time. In this regard, “Mulan” fizzles so badly that both American and Chinese viewers can see right through Mulan is a great movie that can be enjoyed by viewers of all ages regardless of the historical inaccuracies. And it was a slow start. Despite being based on a Chinese tale with Chinese actors, the movie did Sep 11, 2020 · Historical inaccuracies still feature however, perhaps most prominently the use of Fujian tulou for Mulan’s home — structures that wouldn’t be built until for another 1,000 years or so after the Northern Wei. Another obvious nod to Han superiority in the film is through the ethnic othering of the Rourans. Perhaps most Sep 3, 2020 · Disney's new live-action revamp of 'Mulan' hits streaming as an action-packed, showtune-free improvement on the 1998 film about a female warrior. Scholars generally consider Mulan to be a fictional character. 3, 2020. May 29, 2020 · Hua Mulan is one of the most legendary women of ancient China. The original title still lived on in the form of lyrics. This will likely be very costly for Mulan’s box office, as China is heavily relied upon to bring in money via international ticket sales. 99 USD on top of the monthly subscription fee of $7. Feb 15, 2024 · Mulan fights for many years, gaining honor for her actions and falling in love with a fellow soldier. Sep 10, 2013 · At the end of the movie Sleeping Beauty, our hero and heroine, aka Prince Philip and Princess Aurora, aka the best Disney couple of all time (in a matter of severely biased opinion) share a victory dance because the Princess was awaken from the curse, the evil fairy is dead, and that dress is FABULOUS. “There was a song called Hua Mulan. Female warrior heroines appear in the myths and legends of numerous ancient cultures, sharing many similarities among their tales. A 21st century landscape gave the-powers-that-be a chance to play fixer. You can read the ballad Oct 22, 2013 · Cultural deformation is a kind of cultural borrowing of precious treasures of world culture in which cultural distortion usually occurs to varying degrees due to employment of various adapting strategies such as addition, omission, specification, explicitation and alteration. I will say you should read (if you can find a translation) any of the the Hua Mulan novels/plays as, I will say they mostly far exceeds Disney version in the ideals of gender equality. Sort by: EnclavedMicrostate. Sep 14, 2020 · SACHA PFEIFFER, HOST: Disney released its live-action remake of the movie "Mulan" in theaters in China three days ago. "Whale Rider" filmmaker Niki Caro directs the live-action adaptation of Disney's 1998 animated classic Sep 7, 2020 · World History Encyclopedia. You may have heard that Hua Mulan was a historical figure. The tale most likely originated in the Northern Wei Period Aug 23, 2021 · There are many small historical inaccuracies throughout Mulan. Sep 17, 2020 · "Historical inaccuracies are forgivable, unless you are making claims to authenticity. At the time, there are historical inaccuracies within the film as they pertain to ancestral worship; Sep 10, 2020 · Do better, Disney. Mulan is based on the story of Hua Mulan, a character in a sixth century Chinese poem. 5. Sep 15, 2020 · It is safe to say that three weeks is not enough to understand the rich history of China and that these historical inaccuracies invited criticisms to the film. In Chinese “Huā” means “flower” and “Mùlán Feb 21, 2024 · Historical Accuracy in Mulan While “Mulan” is set in Imperial China, it is important to note that the film takes creative liberties in its portrayal of historical events. Mulan is based on a tale that’s been adapted Sort by: QuickSpore. However, the Great Wall of China, which was featured in the Disney retelling of the story, was primarily built by the Ming Dynasty, who ruled from 1368 to Oct 24, 2020 · YAMS?!Mulan-era Makeup Infographics: https://www. However, it is also one of the movies in which historical fact really ruins the whole Jul 11, 2019 · Disney's Mulan Trailer Trashed in China Over Historical Inaccuracies. Dec 26, 2014 · Book News: Egypt Bans Ridley Scott's 'Exodus' For 'Historical Inaccuracies' : The Two-Way Censors say the film takes liberties with its source material, the Book of Exodus, especially its Sep 10, 2020 · After its release was delayed due to the ongoing pandemic, Mulan premiered on Disney+ on September 4, 2020 with an additional Premiere Access price of $29. It is based on the Chinese legend of Hua Mulan and was Disney's 36th animated feature. In the past, Disney has come under fire for inaccurately telling the story of Pocahontas and Mar 25, 2022 · Disney's "Mulan," the 1998 animated film about a young, fearless girl who impersonates a man to enlist into the Chinese military, is a story that has been told and retold for over 1,500 years. Doubtful the Paul Frank look would go down well with real Tang dynasty people. World History Encyclopedia, 07 Sep 2020. Additionally, there’s no Li Shang and no Mushu the dragon, omissions that irked some people. Is there a truth to the modern incarnation of Sep 7, 2020 · Mulan (“magnolia”) is a legendary character in Chinese literature who is best known in the modern day from the Disney filmed adaptations (1998, 2020). Mulan Disney. 99 USD. Helped by her outrageously funny guardian dragon Mushu and a lucky cricket named Cri-Kee, Mulan fights for the respect of her fellow Nov 11, 2018 · inaccuracies such as the episode with the matchmaker, the presence of the Huns, the presence of the shrine to the ancestors, the clothing, and presenting villains as darker-skinned. be/jpw9myIsuMM♥ Join my Patreon for reactions and content: https://www. And some eagle-eyed people spotted historical inaccuracies in the trailer. She was nearly killed by Shang Li, as the penalty for a woman impersonating a soldier is death. ”. Rather, historical records show that he had had mastered differential and integral calculus by the age of 15. Rather than aiming for strict historical accuracy, the filmmakers focused on creating a compelling narrative that would resonate with audiences. Sticklers pointed out how the Huns never invaded China. Regarding the historical inaccuracies, this is a conundrum that is not easily answered. Photo: Tumblr/Disney Mulan comes from Chinese folklore and her story takes place 386 – 538 A. Again, there is no evidence that Mulan existed, and if Mulan was in the first Han Empire campaign, she would be around 560 years old. The historical Powhatan ( known to history as Pocahontas) was a child, not a young woman, while John Smith was a grizzly bearded ex-pirate with a penchant for killing Ottoman Turks. ” This poem was first transcribed in the 6th century during the Northern Wei Dynasty. San Souci and screenplay by Rita Hsiao, Philip LaZebnik, Chris Sanders Jan 25, 2000 · I checked Chinese history in an attemp to place Shan Yu, the Hun leader in the movie. Sep 17, 2020 · Historical inaccuracies are forgivable, unless you are making claims to authenticity. Some historians believe that Hua Mulan was not a real person because the story has several inconsistencies with historical facts and possibly combines myth with legend. Sep 4, 2015 · 3. Sep 4, 2020 · “The Ballad of Mulan,” a 330-word poem about a woman posing as a man to enlist in the military in place of her ailing father, is dated sometime between Wei of the Northern dynasties (386-534 Mar 26, 2020 · 💻Go to https://nordvpn. a Hun leader Aug 27, 2020 · According to director Niki Caro, “Mulan” (2020) has completely deviated from the 1998 film. Jul 11, 2019 · "Whale Rider" filmmaker Niki Caro directs the live-action adaptation of Disney's 1998 animated classic. Release Date: June 19, 1998. Jul 23, 2021 · The heartbreaking life of Pocahontas was one of tragedy and violence - the story of a young girl who was brutally raped, kidnapped, and allegedly murdered by those who were meant to keep her safe. There are content deformation and linguistic deformation in Mulan Sep 4, 2020 · Sept. With the ever-growing popularity of the Broadway hit Hamilton: An American Musical and period dramas like The Crown, audiences have a new fondness for history. June 30, 2017. Its nominally set in the Han era, but uses a post Han era enemy (and one that never directly fought China), while using a lot of much later styles (Song Dynasty Jun 16, 2023 · Part of the Disney Renaissance saw the release of Mulan in 1998: a gorgeous animated film that told the tale of a woman heading into battle against the Huns in a time of war in China. Jan 27, 2024 · Mulan’s story is believed to have originated from an ancient Chinese poem called “The Ballad of Mulan. I did my movie essay on the historical inaccuracies in the Disney film 'Mulan'. While the poem does not provide historical evidence, it has been passed down through generations, becoming an integral part of Chinese folklore. Movie Mistakes pointed out all the errors, many of which have to do with the Feb 3, 2024 · The rich history behind Mulan, beyond Disney's cinematic adaptations, spans over 1,500 years. Jun 10, 2024 · Will Mulan get boycotted?! Looks like politics have crept into pop culture yet again. In that historical period, poor people didn’t have dreams that they could move up in society. Her story, however, about a young girl who takes her father's place in the army to help save her country, is hundreds of years old. Mulan-era Makeup Infographics: https://www. The ballad narrates Mulan's courageous decision to replace her father in the military, disguising herself Sep 4, 2020 · Chinese viewers spotted some historical inaccuracies in the trailer. Disney took pains to ensure that “Mulan” would appeal to audiences in China, but the film Jul 11, 2019 · The internet in China has exploded with excitement over Disney ’s viral new “ Mulan ” trailer, but some have bemoaned the glaring historical and geographical inaccuracies in the short clip Sep 25, 2020 · Visually speaking, “Mulan” is a treasure chest of breathtaking natural and architectural sights. patreon. Hanfugirl also took the initiative to give Mulan a more historically accurate makeover. Mulan was After Returning Home, She Revealed Her Identity. The legend of Mulan is about a young woman who disguises herself as a man to take her own fathers place in the war who was Jul 10, 2019 · In their place is Mulan's new and younger sister. Her heroic actions were first recorded in ancient texts, retold in the famous poem Ballad of Mulan, and later popularized in the 1998 Walt Disney film Mulan. What It Invents: Controversy surrounds the animated Mulan in part due to historical inaccuracies. In reality, John Smith came to her town when Sep 9, 2020 · Many also pointed out historical inaccuracies in terms of costume design and architectural setting of the film. This time, backlash against star Lui Yifei in Disney's live-action movie. Mulan, her family, and her army 8. When her true gender is revealed, the emperor and her fellow soldiers are in awe. Of course, when it comes to popular media . There is no proof that Caesar ever fought in the Third Servile War, or Spartacus's Uprising. Web. Hua Mulan is depicted in the Wu Shuang Pu (無雙譜, Table of Peerless Heroes) by Jin Guliang. It's not a name, but the title of Hsiung Nus' leader. Sep 24, 2020 · Hammond, assistant professor of East Asian history at the University of Arkansas, notes that appropriating non-Han history for the purpose of Han ethnonationalism is akin to “white-washing” in American history. com/p/CEp6ZAQAAeh/Original Mulan 1998 Twitter thread: https://twitter. 5 Share. It told of a young girl (most likely in her early teens) who made the momentous decision to take her father’s place in battle. Mulan’s use of the “Emperor” title should have been changed. Based on the legend of Chinese warrior Hua Mulan, the animated classic tells the story of a young woman struggling to reconcile who she is and what her family expects her to be Jun 26, 2015 · The National Women's History Museum wrote that Pocahontas became ill with tuberculosis or pneumonia while on a ship to go back to America with Rolfe in 1617. Disney’s version of Pocahontas centers John Smith, the man Pocahontas supposedly fell in love with. It failed. Unlike many mythical characters, Mulan’s tale is believed to have some basis in reality, though her exact historical footprint remains elusive. 2. set in ancient China, introduces Hua Mulan as Nov 5, 2020 · Twenty years ago, when “Mulan” originally hit theaters, there were criticisms over the movie’s historical inaccuracies. Around 400 AD, a poem began circulating imperial China. The misunderstanding actually came about due to the fact that people did not understand the Swiss grading system Jun 30, 2017 · Historical Inaccuracies in Popular Media. Based on the legend of teenage warrior Hua Mulan, which was popularized in an ancient Chinese ballad, the heroine disguises herself as Jul 15, 2019 · There's precious little historical evidence concerning Mulan upon which to base all the stories, plays, and now full-length films about her. Mulan is seen living in a tulou hut, a traditional style of roundhouse Sep 8, 2020 · The Shanghai film “Mulan Joins the Army,” from 1939, made during Japan’s occupation of China, became a popular sensation and launched the actress Chen Yunshang into national stardom. Whether Mulan was a real person or not has yet to be determined, but the story itself shows how women can change the course of history. Mulan roams endless grassy open fields, ice-capped mountains and a regal, imposing city that houses the emperor’s palace. Albert Einstein did NOT fail mathematics in school, as is commonly believed. In this regard, “Mulan” fizzles so badly that both American and Chinese viewers can see right through Jul 11, 2019 · Disney’s Live-Action ‘Mulan’ Trailer Criticized in China for Historical Inaccuracies. Protect yourself online Jan 26, 2023 · Let's tackle the most interesting (and controversial) fact first. I finally realize that it should be Chang Yu (as in Mandarin). The response to Mulan in China has been off the charts with a excitement, but there are some who feel Disney dropped the ball Jul 24, 2023 · The production of Mulan was a journey in itself, with a dedicated team of animators, writers, and directors working tirelessly to bring this captivating tale to life. Hua Mulan ( Chinese: 花木蘭) is a legendary Chinese folk heroine from the Northern and Southern dynasties era (4th to 6th century CE) of Chinese history. D. Jan 3, 2020 · Early critics have complained of numerous historical inaccuracies with the source material of Mulan. This case study Sep 14, 2016 · The original movie was riddled with historical inaccuracies. Although she reveals she is a woman at the end of her service In the movie, Mulan is portrayed as an awkward, tomboy girl who has no clue how to act in Chinese society as a young girl. Narratives such as Mulan suggest that people of another race other than whites are less entitled to a life of leisure and privilege. 3. Oct 18, 2021 · Disney movies aren't known for their historical accuracy. Then we talk about something Nov 3, 2019 · The original work that was the 'Ballad of Mulan" is lost to history; however it was well documented enough to make its way into Chinese literature and popular culture as Disney has shown with its movie. Today, her story continues to be told in schools across China. Mulan as depicted in the album Gathering Gems of Beauty (畫麗珠萃秀) (Qing dynasty; ca 18th century). As an addition to u/cthulhushrugged 's posts, u/JimeDorje won the Best of October award for this post detailing what the original Mulan tales were trying to convey. At the beginning of the movie, Aladdin is convinced that things are going to change and that he will someday live in a castle. But a poll on Weibo when that first trailer came out found that over 115,000 users were "satisfied" with what they knew of the This copy of The Ballad of Mulan was written by Song dynasty calligrapher Mi Fu in 1094 AD (Public domain). instagram. In the Chinese legend, however, her identity is never “discovered. It was directed by Tony Bancroft and Barry Cook, with a story by Robert D. Aladdin’s dreams are totally unrealistic. A bit off topic; I once wrote a paper in college comparing the tradtional story, to the Disney remix/adaption. Time to crush some childhoods. She is guided by a guardian dragon‚ named Mushu‚ who is trying to regain his status with the ancestors. the Huns from Mongolia. 9. In this regard, 'Mulan' fizzles so badly that both American and Chinese viewers can see right through Disney's Jun 19, 1998 · 1h 27min. The film’s development process involved extensive research to ensure historical accuracy while infusing it with the magic of Disney storytelling. " We know that Hua Mulan is a character within a folktale, the earliest recorded copy of which is the Ballad of Mulan. The most obvious change is the creation of a talking, fire Oct 31, 2020 · Tang ladies will only paint the center part of their lips to create the illusion of small cherry lips (樱桃小嘴). com/p/CEp6ZAQAAeh/Preorder my book IRON WIDOW, a Pacific Rim meets the Handmaid's Tale Sep 11, 2020 · Walt Disney Co’s live-action war epic Mulan opened to a lukewarm reception in China on Friday as it battled mixed reviews, COVID-19 curbs on cinemas and a government ban on major media coverage Jun 10, 2021 · The showing of Disney cartoon film Mulan in 1998 brought this Chinese old story to countless audiences all around the world and it also meant that Mulan became one of Disney princesses. com/supportbunny♥ Reacting to Histo In order to meet the demand of film creation and cater to the market, Disney has announced more and more real-life adaptation projects, such as the upcoming Mulan, Miss and Tramp and Sword in the Stone, but not all films involving foreign cultures have a good response, sometimes they even lead to criticism. Eurocentrism? Mulan was also released on Disney+ for $30 in response to the delays of the Coronavirus pandemic. Literary Beginnings: The ballad narrates Mulan’s decision to take her aging Sep 16, 2020 · The fourth writer joined the team sometime later and remained on the project after our job was completed. Most historians placed Mulan in a much later time, Northern Wei during South - North Dynasties (AD 396 -581), or even Tang Dynasty (AD 618 - 906). Clever Mulan disguises herself as a male soldier named "Ping" to bravely take her father's place in the Imperial Army. Of the several hundred Disney movies released over the years, the vast majority of them occur in fictional or hyperbolic worlds. In the movie. Sep 11, 2020 · The question of historical accuracy, and whether the film should strive to be completely faithful to the original legend, is not so simple to answer. The scenery brings a realistic attractiveness to the original animation. com/FlashgitzAnimsSpecial thanks to our Patron Producers Sep 17, 2020 · Historical inaccuracies are forgivable, unless you are making claims to authenticity. “Based on a true story” is a popular and effective claim in the marketing realm. Oct 10, 2020 · Pocahontas (1995) Disney’s Pocahontas attempted to respectfully depict Native American culture. Dec 10, 2021 · 2. In fact, they're not really known for their historical anything. Our animated historical documentary series on the history of China continues with a video on the legendary Mulan. Fundamentally, what we know about Mulan comes from an anonymous, medium-length (65 lines in the translation of Arthur Waley [1889-1966]) ballad dating to around the 5th-6th century. Nov 10, 2014 · More specifically, the present analysis investigates the process that Disney appropriated the Chinese legend of Mulan into a “universal” classic and offers an interpretation of The Ballad of Mulan, upon which the Disney film was based, as a form of counter-rhetoric for negotiating the dominant image produced by Disney. The film is about a young woman who disguises Jul 11, 2019 · The internet in China has exploded with excitement over Disney’s viral new “Mulan” trailer, but some have bemoaned the glaring historical and geographical inaccuracies in the short clip Albert Einstein failed mathematics in school. Any kind of dreams were unrealistic in that period. Both versions side by side below. While the oldest written Nov 17, 2023 · ♥ Watch previous video here: https://youtu. Also I call bullshit on the idea that the original ballad of Mulan is only about filial duty or that Chinese people think it should only be about that. This one angers architecture fans everywhere — but, like, only architecture fans. Just like how if you search for Mulan on twitter there are people complaining about historical inaccuracies and deviations from the original, the same is true in China. As Columbia University notes, at the time The Ballad of Mulan was written, China was divided between north and south: We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. • 7 yr. Mulan is described as a three in one feature film: comedy, action movie, and musical. 1. For example, the Disney movie Mulan depicts historical inaccuracies, such as Mulan meeting the Emperor in the Forbidden City, which did not exist during the Han Dynasty Jul 15, 2020 · The Disney movie also has some major historical misrepresentations. May 23, 2024 · “Mulan” came out in 1998, just one month before I turned 7. kq xx wo vl mf ir qt cx sm oy